Is it possible to put (xxxxx).html(data) in a for loop where the xxxx variable changes each time?

I honestly feel like I've tried everything. I'm trying to fill up an HTML table with JSONP data from a looping ajax call where the URL changes each time. The same callback function is used every time, but, obviously, I keep overwriting the data that is to be sent to the HTML table tags because I can't figure out a way to dynamically change these variables.

Basically, I want the first time the callback function is called to store data in something like...

$(#p1_points).html(data_from_ajax_call)

The second time I want it to do...

$(#p2_points).html(data_from_ajax_call)

I've tried silly things like (inside a for loop) doing ...

$(#p + i + _points).html(data_from_ajax_call)

and all sorts of fun stuff, but it doesn't accept arguments of any kind... So, any thoughts? Is this trivial and I'm just over-thinking and under-sleeping it?

Thanks in advance for any help.

UPDATING FOR CLARITY

My ajax calls look like this...

for (var i = 0; i < thisweeksraiders.length; i++){

    $.ajax({

        url:http://us.battle.net/api/wow/character/aerie-peak/ + thisweeksraiders[i] + ?jsonp=myCallback,

        type:GET,

        data: { fields: items, professions, talents, progression},

        dataType:jsonp,

        contentType:application/json,

        jsonpCallback:myCallback,

        success:function(data1){

        }

    })

}

and my callback function looks like this...

function myCallback(data1) {

        //itemscounter += 1;

        var hascloak = No;

        var possupgrades = 30;

        var offhandequipped = false;

        var tempupgrades = 0;

        var tierequipped = 0;

        for (var i = 0; i < gearlist.length; i++){

            if (data1.items[(gearlist[i])].tooltipParams.upgrade)

                tempupgrades += data1.items[(gearlist[i])].tooltipParams.upgrade.current;

        }

        for (var i = 0; i < tierlist.length; i++){

            if(data1.items[(tierlist[i])].tooltipParams.set)

                tierequipped += 1;

        }

        if (data1.items.offHand){

            tempupgrades += data1.items.offHand.tooltipParams.upgrade.current;

            offhandequipped = true;

        }

        if (offhandequipped)

            possupgrades = 32;

        if(data1.items[(gearlist[3])].quality == 5)

            hascloak = Yes;

        $(#p1_cloak).html(hascloak);

        $(#p1_tier).html(tierequipped + /5);

        $(#p1_achieve).html(data1.achievementPoints);

        $(#p1_iLevelE).html(data1.items.averageItemLevelEquipped);

        $(#p1_upgrades).html(tempupgrades + / + possupgrades);

        var totalnormalkills = 0;

        var totalheroickills = 0;

        var furthestboss = null;

        for (var i = 0; i < soobosslist.length; i++){

            totalnormalkills += data1.progression.raids[31].bosses[i].normalKills;

            totalheroickills += data1.progression.raids[31].bosses[i].heroicKills;

        }

        if (totalheroickills == 0){

            for (var i = 14; i > 0; i--){

                if (data1.progression.raids[31].bosses[i-1].normalKills > 0){

                    furthestboss = i + N;

                    break;

                }

            }

        }

        else {

            for (var i = 14; i > 0; i--){

                if (data1.progression.raids[31].bosses[i-1].heroicKills > 0){

                    furthestboss = i + H;

                    break;

                }

            }

        }

        $(#p1_normalkills).html(totalnormalkills);

        $(#p1_heroickills).html(totalheroickills);

        $(#p1_xp).html(furthestboss);

        var classtemp;

        var colortemp;

        switch(data1.class){

        case 1: classtemp = Warrior; colortemp = #C79C6E; break;

        case 2: classtemp = Paladin; colortemp = #F58CBA; break;

        case 3: classtemp = Hunter; colortemp = #ABD473; break;

        case 4: classtemp = Rogue; colortemp = #FFF569; break;

        case 5: classtemp = Priest; colortemp = #FFFFFF; break;

        case 6: classtemp = Death Knight; colortemp = #C41F3B; break;

        case 7: classtemp = Shaman; colortemp = #0070DE; break;

        case 8: classtemp = Mage; colortemp = #69CCF0; break;

        case 9: classtemp = Warlock; colortemp = #9482C9; break;

        case 10: classtemp = Monk; colortemp = #00FF96; break;

        case 11: classtemp = Druid; colortemp = #FF7D0A; break;

        }

        $(#p1_classspec).html(<font color= + colortemp + ><b> + data1.name + </b></font><font size='-1' color= + colortemp + ><em> ( + data1.talents[0].spec.name + )</em></font>);

        var profstemp = (data1.professions.primary[0].name +  &  + data1.professions.primary[1].name);

        $(#p1_profs).html(profstemp);

    }

So, basically, all the #p1 stuff I could put at the end of the function, but I'd like to change it all to $p2 to fill in the next row on my table. The HTML should be obvious, but here it is...

<body>

<center>

<table width=100% border=0>

  <tr>

    <td id=p1_classspec>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p1_iLevelE>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p1_upgrades>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p1_cloak>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p1_tier>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p1_profs>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p1_achieve>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p1_normalkills>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p1_heroickills>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p1_xp>&nbsp;</td>

  </tr>

  <tr>

    <td id=p2_classspec>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p2_iLevelE>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p2_upgrades>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p2_cloak>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p2_tier>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p2_profs>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p2_achieve>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p2_normalkills>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p2_heroickills>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p2_xp>&nbsp;</td>

  </tr>

  <tr>

    <td id=p3_classspec>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p3_iLevelE>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p3_upgrades>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p3_cloak>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p3_tier>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p3_profs>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p3_achieve>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p3_normalkills>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p3_heroickills>&nbsp;</td>

    <td id=p3_xp>&nbsp;</td>

  </tr>

</table>

</center>

</body>

If you follow this link, you'll see what I'm going for (this is not using the for loop). I just want to drastically cut down on my code.

http://www.mynextbit.com/Pages/Wreckedified/test2.html

One more Update for Patrick...

$(document).ready(function(){

        for (var i = 0; i < thisweeksraiders.length; i++){

            (function(index)

                window.jsonpCallbacks[myCallback + index] = function(data){

                    myCallback(data,index);

                };

        })(i);

            $.ajax({

                url:http://us.battle.net/api/wow/character/aerie-peak/ + thisweeksraiders[i] + ?jsonp=jsonpCallbacks.myCallback + i,

                type:GET,

                data: { fields: items, professions, talents, progression},

                dataType:jsonp,

                contentType:application/json,

                jsonpCallback:jsonpCallbacks.myCallback+i,

                success:function(data1){

                }

            })

        }



    });